You are here

Retrospective database research in pediatric cardiology and congenital heart surgery: an illustrative example of limitations and possible solutions.

TitleRetrospective database research in pediatric cardiology and congenital heart surgery: an illustrative example of limitations and possible solutions.
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2012
AuthorsZampi, JD, Donohue, JE, Charpie, JR, Yu, S, Hanauer, DA, Hirsch, JC
JournalWorld J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg
Volume3
Issue3
Pagination283-7
Date Published2012 Jul 1
ISSN2150-136X
Abstract

BACKGROUND: Secondary use of data, whether from clinical information systems or registries, for carrying out clinical research in rare diseases is a common practice but is fraught with potential errors. We sought to elucidate some of the limitations of database research and describe possible solutions to overcome these limitations.METHODS: Using a disease model of a rare postsurgical outcome, we evaluated the ability of four different data sources to correctly identify patients who had that outcome both as individual databases and also when used in conjunction with each other. These results were compared with manual chart review.RESULTS: The sensitivity of the various databases to pick up a rare and specific outcome was poor (9.9%-37%), while the specificities were fairly good (91%-96.7%). By combining the databases, the sensitivity was increased to as much as 56.8% without a large decrease in the specificity (85.2%-91.6%). The electronic medical record (EMR) search engine had the highest sensitivity (96.9%) and a high specificity (89.3%) with a very high negative predictive value (99.4%).CONCLUSION: For rare and specific diseases or outcomes, a single data source search methodology can miss large numbers of patients and potentially bias study results. Combining overlapping databases can improve the ability to capture these rare diseases or outcomes. While chart review remains the most accurate way to obtain complete case capture, new tools like EMR search engines can facilitate the efficiency of this process without sacrificing search quality.

DOI10.1177/2150135112440462
Alternate JournalWorld J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg
PubMed ID23804858
People: 
David Hanauer
University of Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center at North Campus Reserach Complex
1600 Huron Parkway, Bldg 100, Rm 100 
Mailing Address: 2800 Plymouth Rd, NCRC 100-1004
Ann Arbor, MI 48109-2800 
Ph. (734) 764-8848 Fax. (734) 615-0517
Please acknowledge the Cancer Center Support Grant (P30 CA046592) when publishing manuscripts or abstracts that utilized the services of the University of Michigan's Comprehensive Cancer Center's Shared Resource: Cancer Informatics.
Suggested language: "Research reported in this [publication/press release] was supported by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health under award number P30CA046592."

Copyright © Cancer Center Informatics-2011 Regents of the University of Michigan